HRC-S Quantum Efficiencey VerificationCross-Cal HRC-S with ACIS-S3 using SN Remnant G21.5-0.9Deron Pease, K. Tabetha Hole, Hank Donnelly |
For this study we employed the supernova remnant G21.5-0.9 to perform cross-calibration of HRC-S (ObsID 147) with ACIS-S3 (ObsIDs 159,1230), for energies greater than 1.0 keV.
Norbert Schulz provided a power-law source model which he derived
from the ACIS-S3 observations (see model below).
Using the current state of the HRC-S QE model (version 1.1),
Dick Edgar built/formatted the HRC response function with which
we were able to generate predicted HRC-S counts using
the "fakeit" command in XSPEC (version 10).
The predicted counts with total model uncertainties are:
   5462   ±   11.3%
The HRC-S observed counts were extracted from a box around the source
[tdetx(23721:24430),tdety(1837:2494); 1 HRC-S pixel = 6.429um],
corresponding to the size of Norbert's ACIS box
[tdetx(4080:4270),tdety(2136:2312); 1 ACIS-S pixel = 24.0um].
A very large HRC-S background region was defined as the active detector
minus the source region.
The background-subtracted observed counts are:    5816
  ±   1.8%
The source model derived from ACIS-S3 has an uncertainty of 5.3%.
The HRC-S QE over this range has an additional uncertainty of ~10%.
Thus, the total model uncertainty resulting from convolving the source model
with the model of the HRC-S response becomes ~11.3%.
So even though HRC-S actually sees 6.5% more
(absolute difference)
than predicted by our model, the observed matches the predicted within
the 11.3% total model uncertainty.
1) NORBERT's MODEL for G21.5-0.9 derived from ACIS-S3 mo = wabs[1]( powerlaw[2] ) Model Fit Model Component Parameter Unit Value par par comp 1 1 1 wabs nH 10^22 2.119 +/- 0.3929E-01 2 2 2 powerlaw PhoIndex 1.919 +/- 0.3259E-01 3 3 2 powerlaw norm 1.7820E-02 +/- 0.8404E-03 source model uncertainity of 5.3%
Last modified: 09/25/12
The Chandra X-Ray
Center (CXC) is operated for NASA by the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory. 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 USA. Email: cxcweb@head.cfa.harvard.edu Smithsonian Institution, Copyright © 1998-2004. All rights reserved. |